Okay, first of all, this was a really well done episode in terms of acting(especially from Mack and Rosenbaum, more on that later).
Now, onto the story.
They killed off Jonathan so Lana wouldn't have to die.
Re-read that a few times, while thinking back to episodes like "Thirst" and "Spell".
You know that primal scream Reeve does after he lowers Lois' dead body to the ground in Superman: The Movie? You can probably see where I'm going with this.
There's not really much else to say about that.
Also, WTF was with Clark flying Lana up onto the ice cliff in the first scene?! He did NOT jump. Period. He didn't bend his legs or anything!
It was just like "Oh by the way, he can fly now. He's been doing it for a while, we just forgot to tell you. Our bad."
?!
The biggest saving grace was Rosenbaum's first scene. He deserves an Emmy for it. His half-drunk, devastated, dead-serious performance was the best one he's given in the series, narrowly beating out his final confrontation with Lionel at the end of "Memoria" in Season 3.
Allison Mack was also really great, because she was playing it cool and happy but you could tell she was pretty hurt that she's not the only one who knows Clark's secret anymore.
Welling and Kreuk were both at the top of their game too.
The funeral at the end was superb, and would've been even more so if I wasn't blinded by rage at the Pa-for-Lana cop-out.
Seeing Lois 'dead' on the floor was easily my most satisfyed moment this season. Oh, well.
I have to give this a 4.5 out of 5, because it was a quality episode, but seriously, Jonathan swapped for Lana?
What the HELL!:evil: