Random
Didn't **** any of those *****es
Oh I'm sure, but its still just so out of left field and contradicts the perdiction.I'm sure the motivations for Claire leaving Aaron with the other survivors (or leaving him for them to find anyway) will be explained somehow next season. Lost is really good at fleshing out motivations for the characters and usually turning on its head whatever preconceived notions you had about them and their situations. I'm not sure it'll make sense by the end of Season 5, but certainly by the end of the show in Season 6.
I think of it as Desmond lied to get the people rescued... He's Hume-an.
I'm thinking either that or Christian's interaction changed the future.
Still the problem feels like they had aaron with Kate and forgot to think of a reason why claire isn't there and threw something together without thinking it initially through