Marvel Cinematic Universe - Timeline (Part 3)

Dallas Kinard said:
You do realize that just because I'm alone in my views on this specific thread, doesn't mean I'm wrong right? Just because more people agree with something, doesn't make that something correct.
Click to expand...

True, but I'm still gonna use the toothpaste 9/10 doctors recommend. A little common sense shows in a situation where there's multiple people who have dedicated much time and passion to a topic and one disagrees with all the others, chances are the one isn't right. I'll take those odds.
 
Starvel said:
True, but I'm still gonna use the toothpaste 9/10 doctors recommend. A little common sense shows in a situation where there's multiple people who have dedicated much time and passion to a topic and one disagrees with all the others, chances are the one isn't right. I'll take those odds.
Click to expand...
We've all dedicated time and passion to this. I have eyes and can trust them just as much as anyone. So if 9/10 Doctors recommend a brand of cigarettes, that doesn't make cigarettes healthy.
 
Dallas Kinard said:
Except for on-screen evidence.
Click to expand...
I've gave evidence why you can't always go off that but go on. The point is that Marvel Studios chose to place it in Fall 2024, if they saw it any later they would have easily placed it that way in the book. Essentially you're saying you know more about the timeline than the company actually behind it. I'm done with this conversation because it seems all you want to do is argue until someone says you're right.
 
Rman said:
I've gave evidence why you can't always go off that but go on. The point is that Marvel Studios chose to place it in Fall 2024, if they saw it any later they would have easily placed it that way in the book. Essentially your saying you know more about the timeline than the company actually behind it.
Click to expand...
It could have been an over-sight because humans make this stuff and make mistakes (remember 8 years later in Homecoming?).
 
Dallas Kinard said:
It could have been an over-sight because humans make this stuff and make mistakes (remember 8 years later in Homecoming?).
Click to expand...
And if it's an oversight, they'll fix it, but for now there's no reason to believe it is. Do you believe Black Panther is an oversight because it's weather doesn't match June/July ? These things happen with fictional universes and sometimes you have to let it go.
 
Dallas Kinard said:
We've all dedicated time and passion to this. I have eyes and can trust them just as much as anyone. So if 9/10 Doctors recommend a brand of cigarettes, that doesn't make cigarettes healthy.
Click to expand...
But doctors don't agree on that because their experience that allows them to form their opinion to say otherwise. Likewise people could agree with you but the time and passion we've put into doing this says otherwise for you. You can make up a weird scenario to try and prove your point but that still just means it's a made up scenario to make you right
 
Rman said:
And if it's an oversight, they'll fix it, but for now there's no reason to believe it is. Do you believe Black Panther is an oversight because it's weather doesn't match June/July ? These things happen with fictional universes and sometimes you have to let it go.
Click to expand...
I never said that weather is always perfect evidence. If the story itself trumps the smaller background details, then I concede. But we have to take each scene by itself and judge it. You can't apply Black Panther rules to Doc Strange. Two separate chapters.
 
Dallas Kinard said:
I think weather/trees are solid evidence at times. This is my opinion. So therefore it IS an opinion thing.
Click to expand...
It's not weather. It's just trees, and trees are known for being occasionally unique when it comes to how they react to the changing of seasons.
 
Starvel said:
But doctors don't agree on that because their experience that allows them to form their opinion to say otherwise. Likewise people could agree with you but the time and passion we've put into doing this says otherwise for you. You can make up a weird scenario to try and prove your point but that still just means it's a made up scenario to make you right
Click to expand...
I'm not making anything up though. Anyone can watch the film for themselves and SEE the evidence I'm pointing out lol
 
Dallas Kinard said:
I never said that weather is always perfect evidence. If the story itself trumps the smaller background details, then I concede. But we have to take each scene by itself and judge it. You can't apply Black Panther rules to Doc Strange. Two separate chapters.
Click to expand...
Both are examples where the timeline tells us one thing, while the weather another. I don't see much difference.
 
SoyaCS said:
It's not weather. It's just trees, and trees are known for being occasionally unique when it comes to how they react to the changing of seasons.
Click to expand...
I mean, it IS weather, which affects the trees. Also see how everyone is dressed. It's clearly early fall, not late fall like it was earlier in the film.
 
Dallas Kinard said:
I'm not making anything up though. Anyone can watch the film for themselves and SEE the evidence I'm pointing out lol
Click to expand...
You're making up a scenario saying 9/10 doctors could agree smoking is bad. But they don't. And you can keep pointing out your evidence but unless something changes you're not going to persuade people
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Back
Top