Lost *spoilers*

Was that Mr. Friendly, by the way? Going by Mike?

Desmond can predict the future... Accurately. Sweet.

Mike? The guy running the commune? As Hurley might say, "Ummm... dude, that was a totally different actor."

Can Desmond PREDICT the future... or is he FROM the future? Looked like a little time travel a la Terminator (show up buck naked) to me.
 
Mike? The guy running the commune? As Hurley might say, "Ummm... dude, that was a totally different actor."

Can Desmond PREDICT the future... or is he FROM the future? Looked like a little time travel a la Terminator (show up buck naked) to me.
That's what I assumed. All that electromagnetism can probably do some crazy ****.

Great episode tonight, best of the season so far. I love Locke again. That's a great feeling.

I can see them "getting back to their action adventure roots". A lot of action and a lot of humor.
 
Desmond being a time traveller? That would extremely weird... Just think of what wrong the writers could do with that angle. I'm not knocking the writer's ability, I'm just wondering what the significance will be. Desmond is still my boy, though. I heard that someone might get super powers, but I never pegged it on him.

I would have to agree that this was the better of three episodes we've seen so far... But I'm pleasantly surprised - Season 3 has been a very consistently strong season thus far. I thought it would fall apar after the Season 2 finale, but I've been proved wrong. The writer's are incorporating all sorts of goodness, even from the very beginning of the show. That, to me, is awesome.
 
These first 3 episodes really are going to be awesome when viewed back to back to back. Definitely couldn't say that with as much certainty about season 2; the Michael episode didn't do much for me, and the hatch moments just kept getting replayed over and over again. But now we've gotten to see Others, new Others, Jack and the two "lovebirds," Sayid and the two "love"birds, and all of the beach folk.

Still no Ms. Klugh, though. :)
 
Desmond being a time traveller? That would extremely weird... Just think of what wrong the writers could do with that angle. I'm not knocking the writer's ability, I'm just wondering what the significance will be.
My two cents: Desmond is neither a precog OR a "time-traveller" per se -- I think he exists in a time period just a few minutes ahead of the other characters, or perhaps time is looping around him (think Quicksilver's post-House of M powers; or, if he can't control it, more like Donnie Darko, all that "tangent reality/Living Reciever" stuff).

Another possibility: reality is warped around him, so that he sees ALL time as one continuous, fluid moment -- like Doc Manhattan in Watchmen. Hence all that "See you in another life, Brother" stuff during Jack's flashback; perhaps he already knew then that they would meet again.
 
Last edited:
My two cents: Desmond is neither a precog OR a "time-traveller" per se -- I think he exists in a time period just a few minutes ahead of the other characters, or perhaps time is looping around him (think Quicksilver's post-House of M powers; or, if he can't control it, more like Donnie Darko, all that "tangent reality/Living Reciever" stuff).

Another possibility: reality is warped around him, so that he sees ALL time as one continuous, fluid moment -- like Doc Manhattan in Watchmen. Hence all that "See you in another life, Brother" stuff during Jack's flashback; perhaps he already knew then that they would meet again.

No, I'm not buying the bit about the flashbacks. The destruction of the hatch is what caused the change in Desmond. I'm also still championing the time traveller theory because it's the only one where Desmond would KNOW what was different about him. He clearly realized he had made a mistake when speaking to Hurley... as if he had jumped back in time and arrived a few minutes before he had planned. The time traveller theory may very well be wrong, but I haven't heard another one yet that fits the facts.
 
I am beginning to warm up to the fact that Desmond may be a time traveller. It gives us yet another angle to the philosophy going on - we've got Locke, the skeptical believer, Eko, the priest, and Desmond... The prophet. :)
 
I've been brainstorming some ideas for an alternate Lost story where Jack dies in the pilot episode. I've made a thread over at Ideastorm and which appreciate some input.

And to keep this kind of on topic, I've been downloading the latest episode of Lost since Thursday. I hate having no download time.
 
Desmond as a time traveller is a REALLY bad idea in my opinion.

It is really bad.

I keep thinking it would have been cool/weird if at the end of the first episode of Season 3, while Jack is in his cell, the door opens and someone steps in. He looks up and comes face to face with his father, who says, "Son."

LOST!
 
I'm thinking that he can just see the future

I think/hope he just had a vision or a dream after the hatch imploded.

Several people on the island have seen the future before. I'm thinking Desmond had a dream about Locke's speech, and then when Hurley called him on it and he said "oh....right" he meant "oh yeah, it was just a dream", not "oh yeah, it hasn't happened yet".
 
Sweet, I finally saw the episode. Locke Season 1 was the best character ever, and now he's back to that greatness.

Desmond... I hope he's not a time traveller. That would just be stupid. I'm pretty sure he's just having Deja Vu dreams, like I have sometimes. I dream something, take no notice, then something similar happens in real life, and I remember the dream, and it scares me.
 
Desmond... I hope he's not a time traveller. That would just be stupid. I'm pretty sure he's just having Deja Vu dreams, like I have sometimes. I dream something, take no notice, then something similar happens in real life, and I remember the dream, and it scares me.
I've had that same situation happen to me, too.
 
Sweet, I finally saw the episode. Locke Season 1 was the best character ever, and now he's back to that greatness.

Desmond... I hope he's not a time traveller. That would just be stupid. I'm pretty sure he's just having Deja Vu dreams, like I have sometimes. I dream something, take no notice, then something similar happens in real life, and I remember the dream, and it scares me.

That's what I got.
 
I am beginning to warm up to the fact that Desmond may be a time traveller. It gives us yet another angle to the philosophy going on - we've got Locke, the skeptical believer, Eko, the priest, and Desmond... The prophet. :)
Yeah, I really like this assessment! Execept, after the vision in the sweat lodge, it feels like Locke is no longer merely the "skeptical believer" -- he's now a full-on Shaman. So we now have a broader range of spiritual roles being played out on the show.

But here's where things get interesting...

If we have characters on the 'good' side, the Losties, occupying those roles, do they have opposite numbers among the 'bad' side, The Others?

See, we often have the idea of evil as being represented by a single, shizo Adversary, with multiple sides to its personality (see, for example, the otherwise excellent Fables); but historically, "evil" took on various forms: The Devil (associated with Challenging or Tempting the good ones, but as a way of testing them, as oppposed to outright corrupting them), Satan/"The King of Babylon" (who is meant to be evil personified, and thus 'naturally' opposed to the good ones), and Death/Despair (representing the inevitable entropy of natural goodness; everything ends).

Maybe we ought to keep that in mind, as the roles of specific Others and/or DHARMA employees become more clearly defined.
 
Last edited:
Oh, and one more thing about symbolism on the show:

We have an older lady, defined primarily by her possible insanity, desipte the fact that she *appears* to be coldly rational: Danielle Rousseau, The Crone.

We've got a younger woman, defined largely by her initial condition of impending motherhood, and later on, her "suitability" to be a "good mother": Claire, The Mother.

And now, we're seeing more of the girl who was taken by the Others, and raised by them, precisely because of her presumed innoncence: Alex Rousseau, The Virgin/Maiden.

Could the eventual meeting of these three 'Fates'/'Furies' signal the destruction anticipated, within LOST mythology, by the so-called Valenzetti Equation (from the LOST Experience game)?
 
If we're going by these standards, Ben Linus could easily fall under the Devil category. He offers Jack a way home, for instance, but for a price, you know??
 

Latest posts

Back
Top