All-Star Superman Discussion Thread (Spoilers)

[thee great one]

Read the first issue and I didn't like it. I don't know what you guys see in this and first I hear Lois as supergirl and now Jimmy as Doomsday? That is so lame....

Superwoman.

 

[TheManWithoutFear]

Superwoman.

Are you calling me names?

 

[thee great one]

Are you calling me names?

was that a fat joke?

 

[Doc Comic]

Dude. Superman dying due to being overpowered, Superman being the true person, Lois as Superwoman, Jimmy becomes Doomsday...this is pure Silver Age goodness! How can you NOT like it? This is easily the Superman magnum opus of this decade, perhaps even the past two decades.

 

[ProjectX2]

Read the first issue and I didn't like it. I don't know what you guys see in this and first I hear Lois as supergirl and now Jimmy as Doomsday? That is so lame....

The first issue was bland on it's own. But when you put it into the big picture, it's good.

 

[Bass]

That is the coolest thing I've ever heard.

Only because Morrison can sell it. If this was something X-Men was doing, you'd be going, "ARGH! I HATE THE X-MEN! I'M BURNING ALL MY COMICS AND CLOSING DOWN THE SITE FOR GOOD!



"AND THIS TIME I MEAN IT!"

I mean, just look at it. It's bloody stupid. But because it's being delivered properly, we swallow it.

A lesson for all human kind I feel.

Especially for a man and his woman.

On hindsight, that last sentence was probably unneccessary.

 

[moonmaster]

Read the first issue and I didn't like it. I don't know what you guys see in this and first I hear Lois as supergirl and now Jimmy as Doomsday? That is so lame....

But you like Daredevil, so your opinion doesn't count.

 

[E]

Only because Morrison can sell it. If this was something X-Men was doing, you'd be going, "ARGH! I HATE THE X-MEN! I'M BURNING ALL MY COMICS AND CLOSING DOWN THE SITE FOR GOOD!

That is exactly, precisely, and unequivicably correct.

 

[Ice]

Let's just stick to the topic, shall we?

 

[thee great one]

# Morrison said Krypto will appear in All Star Superman #6 - the Superboy issue. The writer feels that Krypto should only appear in Superboy stories and not Superman stories, because it makes for great, "A boy and his dog" stories.

 

[thee great one]

 

[Bass]

I love this comic.

 

[marvelman]

o hey i hadnt seen that!!!!


AWESOME!!!!!!!!!!!


hahaha.

 

[moonmaster]

Can you say "SuperOz"?

 

[Dr.Strangefate]

Lex does seem to be a little... excited.

 

[Bass]

*looks at the issue cover again*

*reads DSF's post once more*

*looks at the cover*

*burns all his comics*

 

[Ultimate Houde]

Must you comment on everything?

 

[Bass]

Well, if I didn't, how would you 'make up' your own minds.

You need guidance.

And dogmatic fanaticism to me.

 

[Dr.Strangefate]

Well, if I didn't, how would you 'make up' your own minds.

Lots of Blush and Eyeliner?

 

[moonmaster]

# 3-"Sweet Dreams, Superwoman"

An awesome issue once again. Some of my favorite moments:

-Giant, flesh-eating lizards from the Center of the Earth? How awesome is that?
-I loved the whole "Who Can Impress Lois" plotline. Very fun.
-Atom-Hotep: Cool.
-The resolution of the big "competition". I bet Superman could even beat Sylvester Stallone in "Over the Top".
-This:

Needs to be a poster.
-The ending was just so...warm. I really love this book.