Bass
Nexus of the World
Re: Ultimate Avengers (Discussion & Spoilers)
UF4 was definitely the weakest Ultimate title. Millar and Bendis kinda hacked out the concept (at least, compared to the revamps of Spidey, X-Men, and the Avengers) and it just never worked.
ULTIMATUM didn't introduce new characters. It just killed off others.
Millar overuses hype to get out of actually doing any writing. I know that sounds harsh, but Millar is capable of very, very good stories with genuinely interesting characters and events. Unfortunately, he has a tendency to hype not just on his boards, but in the story. Characters say how incredible they are but don't actually do it.
For example, in GRAND THEFT AMERICA, we had each Liberator talk endlessly about how super-powerful they are, but when it came to actually doing anything, the Ultimates just went, "Actually, I'm more badass".
The weird thing is, the more a writer hypes their work inside the work, the greater the audience expectation, which results in them being less satisfied, whereas if he'd been somewhat more understated the payoff may have seemed grander.
So here, we have Greg Stark going on about how smart and brilliant he is... but he hasn't done anything smart or brilliant.
And I bet he never will. :?
Not much really - Fantastic Four is by far the big comic that I'm least familiar with. After reading UFF (which, aside from the first few arcs, was the weakest ultimate ongoing, imo)
UF4 was definitely the weakest Ultimate title. Millar and Bendis kinda hacked out the concept (at least, compared to the revamps of Spidey, X-Men, and the Avengers) and it just never worked.
Ya, I guess that's true - and hopefully Armor Wars will be a good re-telling too, I still haven't picked it up - but for people who, unlike me, have read all the original 616 stories, I think it would be nice for some more new stories and characters. Then again, if it ain't broke, don't fix it I suppose...we don't want another Ultimatum.
ULTIMATUM didn't introduce new characters. It just killed off others.
That's because Millar uses the "remember that guy? well this guy is even MORE awesome" train of thought alot. Making Gregory Stark essentially the Mycroft to Tony's Sherlock Holmes.
Millar overuses hype to get out of actually doing any writing. I know that sounds harsh, but Millar is capable of very, very good stories with genuinely interesting characters and events. Unfortunately, he has a tendency to hype not just on his boards, but in the story. Characters say how incredible they are but don't actually do it.
For example, in GRAND THEFT AMERICA, we had each Liberator talk endlessly about how super-powerful they are, but when it came to actually doing anything, the Ultimates just went, "Actually, I'm more badass".
The weird thing is, the more a writer hypes their work inside the work, the greater the audience expectation, which results in them being less satisfied, whereas if he'd been somewhat more understated the payoff may have seemed grander.
So here, we have Greg Stark going on about how smart and brilliant he is... but he hasn't done anything smart or brilliant.
And I bet he never will. :?
Last edited: