Marvel Cinematic Universe - Timeline (Part 3)

Slyonic said:
Titan Consumed is meant to fit into the MCU timeline. Moreso, it was intended to be MCU canon. But we didn't add that to the timeline either
Click to expand...
To be honest, I think they said it was non-canon because it spoiled Infinity War/Endgame stuff more than anything. Oh well...
 
Megatron said:
then if it doesn't contradict anything, why not?
Click to expand...

We've had discussions about this, but the one spotty article of Marvel saying it's not canon was considered definite proof it shouldn't be on the timeline.
 
things like deadpool or the ghost rider movies don't contradict the mcu but just because they could fit doesn't mean they do; the creators specify for a reason
 
eloesch289 said:
things like deadpool or the ghost rider movies don't contradict the mcu but just because they could fit doesn't mean they do; the creators specify for a reason
Click to expand...
they are different earths, your argument doesn't make sense.

My arguments relates to Earth-199999 things.
 
Slyonic said:
Yes.
Click to expand...
then we should change the netflix series placements.

Post #4 says that the crime rate is decresing, and the public is thanking the avengers (while is obviusly Daredevil or better the man in the mask doing. So that post has to be made before the bombing on hell's kitchen coz after that the crima rate increse, and can't be made after daredevil season 1 coz he is known after he defeats the kingpin.

The post was made in January 23rd 2015.
 
Last edited:
the comments by the creators specifying what isn't canon is the same as two projects being assigned different alternate reality numbers, the numbers aren't given within the projects themselves
 
eloesch289 said:
the comments by the creators specifying what isn't canon is the same as two projects being assigned different alternate reality numbers, the numbers aren't given within the projects themselves
Click to expand...
sometimes they are, also there is an encylopedia....

It's not the same as a tweet.
 
Why don't we vote on including those tie-in comics? Also, it'd be fun to have a separate list with related MCU timelines, such as incompatible comics and the video games. In my opinion, anyway.

For example, Earth-TRN999 (Unofficial Number). That's an interesting one, because the Marvel wiki interprets the PHASE ONE games as a single universe.

1944 - Captain America: Super Soldier Prologue Trailer
1944 - Captain America: Super Soldier
2008 - Iron Man
2008 - Sega Iron Man Special #1, "The Price of Doing Business"
2009 - Thor: God of Thunder Prologue Trailer
2009 - Thor: God of Thunder
2010 - The Incredible Hulk
2010 - Iron Man 2 Prologue Trailer
2010 - Iron Man 2
 
Pro Bot said:
Why don't we vote on including those tie-in comics? Also, it'd be fun to have a separate list with related MCU timelines, such as incompatible comics and the video games. In my opinion, anyway.

For example, Earth-TRN999 (Unofficial Number). That's an interesting one, because the Marvel wiki interprets the PHASE ONE games as a single universe.

1944 - Captain America: Super Soldier Prologue Trailer
1944 - Captain America: Super Soldier
2008 - Iron Man
2008 - Sega Iron Man Special #1, "The Price of Doing Business"
2009 - Thor: God of Thunder Prologue Trailer
2009 - Thor: God of Thunder
2010 - The Incredible Hulk
2010 - Iron Man 2 Prologue Trailer
2010 - Iron Man 2
Click to expand...
I've never considered them canon. Just the ones that have the stamp. To me they just feel like fluff and I feel don't add to the universe in the same way the official ones do (some outright contradicting it) But if a majority wants to add them, have at it.
 
Pro Bot said:
Why don't we vote on including those tie-in comics? Also, it'd be fun to have a separate list with related MCU timelines, such as incompatible comics and the video games. In my opinion, anyway.

For example, Earth-TRN999 (Unofficial Number). That's an interesting one, because the Marvel wiki interprets the PHASE ONE games as a single universe.

1944 - Captain America: Super Soldier Prologue Trailer
1944 - Captain America: Super Soldier
2008 - Iron Man
2008 - Sega Iron Man Special #1, "The Price of Doing Business"
2009 - Thor: God of Thunder Prologue Trailer
2009 - Thor: God of Thunder
2010 - The Incredible Hulk
2010 - Iron Man 2 Prologue Trailer
2010 - Iron Man 2
Click to expand...
As for this, personally I have no interest in taking over a separate timeline for MCU related material but if someone wanted to create this it'd be the perfect place for the "inspired by" comics. I'd also like to see the Thanos novel get a little love there lol I was sad when it was made non-canon
 
I'm happy without the comics tbh my personal timelines only include screen media (E.g. TV,Movies,Video Games,Shorts,etc.) (video games and shorts are cannon if they don't have like a gimmicky advert attached to it like the Loki S02 McDonald's TVA Orientation videos or the recent What if VR experience because of different voice actors, continuity errors & niche availability)

Pretty much all of the Comics were still cannon when we were wrapping up the infinity saga, but since then I feel like marvel studios has done a Star Wars and retconned some of the comics events, big and small in the past couple of years with black widow retconning the ending of Civil War for example.

Basically, they had too much lore to maintain, overwrote some of it and essentially made some of the comics semi or non-cannon.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Back
Top