I don't think of it as a stupid reason at all, they are trying to defend benefits they rightfully should have. The last contract both parties agreed that writers should get so much money in post theater releases, but simply because the format of those post-releases changed in a way no one could have anticipated over 17 years ago, they are not getting the money they rightfully deserve. You kept saying "they get paid for the job the signed to do so they should shut the **** up" but they haven't been paid this percentage of money like they should. Image for a moment you made an agreement that you would writer a movie, get this much for the initial writing, this much for theater tickets, and this much for video cassettes. Now how many people by video cassettes any more? Now all that money they were making from that is gone. So now you are making less money, their income has been cut. essentially the studios took that percentage of videos for themselves. That is really unfair, and the Alliance of Motion Picture and Television Producers are being complete douches taking advantage over writers because entertainment technology took a wrong turn. Trust me this is not a stupid reason, if something similar happened to you in a permanent career, I guarantee you would stand up to it (not nessecarily striking)