DIrishB
The Timeline Guy
I would REALLY prefer Jack Huston, but Joaquin is unquestionably a great actor. I just can't really see him in the part.
That's my opinion as well. Huston looks far closer to Strange on a physical comparison. He's also a great actor, and not as big a star as Phoenix, which would likely open up the possibility for Huston as Strange to appear or at least cameo in The Defenders series a few years down the road. I'm not sure Phoenix would be as open to the idea or as willing to appear on the show.
Either way, both are great actors, and I'd have no problem with Phoenix getting the role, I just think Huston getting it would allow for more crossover appearance possibilities, while still, first and foremost, casting an extremely talented actor for the part.