(Defunct thread)

So, erm... this is canon with Smallville/Snyderverse Darkseid now.
Naw. When they showed TTG in The Red it was on a TV screen. We didn't SEE Harley Quinn in any of those "The Red" bubbles so the same could apply.

Remember when Static Shock was seen on a TV in The Sandman? It's peaking into another multiverse.
 
The Joe Chill episode airing right now is super complicated with the timeline. (No freaking way 50 years makes any sense, that has to be a wild estimation.)

I'll move GK to it's own timeline until we get more answers.
 
What are the chances Gotham Knights is in the same "timeline" as Superman & Lois and that might get 'adjusted' by S&L's series finale?

Like at some point between 1979 and now, the timeline was heavily altered.
 
What are the chances Gotham Knights is in the same "timeline" as Superman & Lois and that might get 'adjusted' by S&L's series finale?

Like at some point between 1979 and now, the timeline was heavily altered.

Don't take this as me moving anything. All hypotheticals lol.
 
Ok, I'm so confused now. Are Titans and Doom Patrol the same Earth or is the version we saw last episode of Titans (thus on 1x04 too) an alternate version who are played mostly by the same actors?
 
I'm a bit confused. Which Earths are canon? I list what I think and you can add what I am missing:
Pre-Crisis:
  • Earth-1: Arrowverse (Arrow, The Flash, Legends of Tomorrow, Vixen…)
  • Earth-9: Titans
  • Earth-38: Supergirl
  • Earth-66: Batman (1966 Series)
  • Earth-76: Wonder Woman (1976 Series)
  • Earth-85: 1985 Crisis on Infinite Earths (?)
  • Earth-89: Batman (1989)
  • Earth-90: The Flash (1990 Series)
  • Earth-96: Superman Returns
  • Earth-167: Smallville
  • Earth-203: Birds of Prey (2003 Series)
  • Earth-666: Lucifer
  • Earth-D: DC Comics Earth-D (?)
  • Earth-F: Superman (1941 Animated Series)
  • Earth-N52: DC Comics New 52 (?)
  • Earth-P: Powerless (?)
  • Earth-X: Freedom Fighters: The Ray
  • Earth-???: Black Lightning
  • Earth-???: DCEU
Post-Crisis:
  • Earth-Prime: Arrowverse
  • Earth-1: DCEU
  • Earth-2: Stargirl, The Batman (?)
  • Earth-9: Titans
  • Earth-12: Green Lantern
  • Earth-19: Swamp Thing
  • Earth-21: Doom Patrol
  • Earth-96: Superman Returns
  • Earth-???: Superman & Lois
  • Earth-???: Joker (?)
 
I'm a bit confused. Which Earths are canon? I list what I think and you can add what I am missing:
Pre-Crisis:
  • Earth-1: Arrowverse (Arrow, The Flash, Legends of Tomorrow, Vixen…)
  • Earth-9: Titans
  • Earth-38: Supergirl
  • Earth-66: Batman (1966 Series)
  • Earth-76: Wonder Woman (1976 Series)
  • Earth-85: 1985 Crisis on Infinite Earths (?)
  • Earth-89: Batman (1989)
  • Earth-90: The Flash (1990 Series)
  • Earth-96: Superman Returns
  • Earth-167: Smallville
  • Earth-203: Birds of Prey (2003 Series)
  • Earth-666: Lucifer
  • Earth-D: DC Comics Earth-D (?)
  • Earth-F: Superman (1941 Animated Series)
  • Earth-N52: DC Comics New 52 (?)
  • Earth-P: Powerless (?)
  • Earth-X: Freedom Fighters: The Ray
  • Earth-???: Black Lightning
  • Earth-???: DCEU
Post-Crisis:
  • Earth-Prime: Arrowverse
  • Earth-1: DCEU
  • Earth-2: Stargirl, The Batman (?)
  • Earth-9: Titans
  • Earth-12: Green Lantern
  • Earth-19: Swamp Thing
  • Earth-21: Doom Patrol
  • Earth-96: Superman Returns
  • Earth-???: Superman & Lois
  • Earth-???: Joker (?)
Pre-Crisis
Earth-1: Arrowverse
Earth-9: Titans
Earth-38: Supergirl
Earth-66: Batman/The Green Hornet
Earth-76: Wonder Woman (1976 Series)
Earth-89: Batman (1989)
Earth-90: The Flash (1990 Series)
Earth-96: Superman Returns
Earth-167: Smallville
Earth-203: Birds of Prey
Earth-666: Lucifer
Earth-F: Superman (1941 Animated Series)
Earth-P: Powerless
Earth-??: Black Lightning
Earth-??: DC Extended Universe

Post-Crisis
Earth-1: DC Extended Universe
Earth-2: Stargirl, The Batman
Earth-9: Titans
Earth-12: Green Lantern
Earth-19: Swamp Thing
Earth-21: Doom Patrol
Earth-66: Batman/The Green Hornet
Earth-76: Wonder Woman (1976 Series)
Earth-90: The Flash (1990 Series)
Earth-96: Superman Returns
Earth-97: Batman (1995)
Earth-167: Smallville
Earth-203: Birds of Prey
Earth-666: Lucifer
Earth-F: Superman (1941 Animated Series)
Earth-P: Powerless
Earth-Prime: Arrowverse
Earth-??: Superman (1978)
Earth-??: Joker
Earth-??: Harley Quinn (2019 Animated Series)
Earth-??: Superman & Lois
Earth-??: The Sandman/Dead Boy Detectives

They confirmed all the pre-crisis Earths based on established movies/shows were restored. All comic-based Earths are variants because it's set in a separate multiverse. TTG isn't canon because obviously that was a TV screen. That would occur in an Animated Multiverse with the DCAMU and Teen Titans I take it.
 
Earth-1: DC Extended Universe
Earth-2: Stargirl, The Batman
Is the Earth-1 DCEU and Earth-2 The Batman just someone from DC trying to explain that the Batman is not canon to the DCEU saying something like "The Batman is like Earth-2 to our DCEU Earth-1"? Because as much as I would like to have more cohesion in the Live-Action Multiverse and more shared universes between multiple mediums like TV and movies, that just sounds like just an example and not actually implying that The Batman is THE Earth-2 from Stargirl.
Earth-??: Joker
Has something actually implied that the Joker is part of all of this multiverse or is just guessing that it will eventually crossover with something?
 
Joker was implied alongside The Batman. I agree that it was absolutely unintentional, but they still said The Batman was Earth-2. I don't think it is, but it's kinda just something you gotta list in these things to be consistent even though it doesn't make sense...
 
Joker was implied alongside The Batman. I agree that it was absolutely unintentional, but they still said The Batman was Earth-2. I don't think it is, but it's kinda just something you gotta list in these things to be consistent even though it doesn't make sense...
Given I doubt it was intentional and there's nothing else confirming it, I just go with them using Earth-2 as a way of explaining they're separate from the DCEU. I think it's more consistent if they aren't treated as the same world.
 
Pre-Crisis
Earth-1: Arrowverse
Earth-9: Titans
Earth-38: Supergirl
Earth-66: Batman/The Green Hornet
Earth-76: Wonder Woman (1976 Series)
Earth-89: Batman (1989)
Earth-90: The Flash (1990 Series)
Earth-96: Superman Returns
Earth-167: Smallville
Earth-203: Birds of Prey
Earth-666: Lucifer
Earth-F: Superman (1941 Animated Series)
Earth-P: Powerless
Earth-??: Black Lightning
Earth-??: DC Extended Universe

Post-Crisis
Earth-1: DC Extended Universe
Earth-2: Stargirl, The Batman
Earth-9: Titans
Earth-12: Green Lantern
Earth-19: Swamp Thing
Earth-21: Doom Patrol
Earth-66: Batman/The Green Hornet
Earth-76: Wonder Woman (1976 Series)
Earth-90: The Flash (1990 Series)
Earth-96: Superman Returns
Earth-97: Batman (1995)
Earth-167: Smallville
Earth-203: Birds of Prey
Earth-666: Lucifer
Earth-F: Superman (1941 Animated Series)
Earth-P: Powerless
Earth-Prime: Arrowverse
Earth-??: Superman (1978)
Earth-??: Joker
Earth-??: Harley Quinn (2019 Animated Series)
Earth-??: Superman & Lois
Earth-??: The Sandman/Dead Boy Detectives

They confirmed all the pre-crisis Earths based on established movies/shows were restored. All comic-based Earths are variants because it's set in a separate multiverse. TTG isn't canon because obviously that was a TV screen. That would occur in an Animated Multiverse with the DCAMU and Teen Titans I take it.
Harley Quinn was only offscreen voices in that Titans episode. I would treat it the same way as TTG. On a TV screen, not existing in this multiverse.
 
Harley Quinn was only offscreen voices in that Titans episode. I would treat it the same way as TTG. On a TV screen, not existing in this multiverse.
I mean, the Injustice videogame has appeared multiple times in the Arrowverse on screen and nobody thinks it is part of the Arrowverse.
 
Are Earth-9 and the other Earths from the Smallville Comics the same as in the Pre-Crisis Arrowverse Multiverse? Haven't read those, so no idea if they would fit, but I heard they had the same designations as established universes.
 
Joker was implied alongside The Batman. I agree that it was absolutely unintentional, but they still said The Batman was Earth-2. I don't think it is, but it's kinda just something you gotta list in these things to be consistent even though it doesn't make sense...
Doesn't Stargirl even mention that there is a Batman in her Universe? Sure, it was not meant to be Battinson, but it's a fun connection
 
Are Earth-9 and the other Earths from the Smallville Comics the same as in the Pre-Crisis Arrowverse Multiverse? Haven't read those, so no idea if they would fit, but I heard they had the same designations as established universes.
Probably no, since the own Smallville series calls the Smallville main universe Earth-1 and its parallel universe Earth-2, when they are not the same as Arrowverse Earth-1 and 2. They could be part of the Pre-Crisis Arrowverse Multiverse but its just that whoever put their numbers has a different criteria than whoever puts them in the Arrowverse.
 
Last edited:
According to Smallville wiki:

Earth-1
The main universe of Smallville, where Superman's adventures take place. Its designation is unknown but it was indicated that it is not the Prime Earth. It remains unclear if this comment will turn out to be true or not. This Earth have commonly been referred to as Earth-1.

Earth-2
This Earth was a parallel universe that co-existed as one with the Earth of the main Smallville universe. When shown, it was always in gray and dull colors. Operating as a metaphorical mirror, all of its residents appeared to be similar and yet different from those of their Earth-1 counterparts. The main difference of this Earth from the other universes is that Kal-El of Krypton was raised by Lionel Luthor instead of the Kents, like on the main Smallville Earth, and as a result he became his world's most powerful super villain, Ultraman. Travel between Earth-2 and the main Earth of Smallville was achieved through the Kryptonian mirror box, or through Jor-El's Fortress of Solitude. It was revealed that Earth-2 was destroyed by the Monitors. Its last survivor was Chloe Sullivan, who succeeded to travel to the main Earth of Smallville but was later killed there by the Monitors.

Earth-9
This Earth was destroyed when it was torn asunder by collision with Earth-37, toppling into one another, because of a Bleed quake caused by a Monitor who did not follow the protocol.

Earth-13
This Earth was a parallel universe that co-existed as one with the Earth of the main Smallville universe. Not much is known about this universe as it was never shown, only merely mentioned. Its main feature was that its version of Clark Kent was a normal human and a wannabe hero, rather than a Kryptonian with super powers, and Bruce Wayne instead of being a superhero is actually a psychopathic killer. Like many other universes, this Earth was also decimated. Earth-13 was destroyed when Earth-9 and 37 were torn asunder by collision, toppling into one another and shattering reality on Earth-13, because of a Bleed quake caused by a Monitor who did not follow the protocol. Its version of Clark managed to travel to the main Earth of Smallville. Unfortunately, he was followed by Bruce and he was killed by him there. Bruce Wayne remains the last survivor of his Earth, as he is held prisoner on Mars.

Earth-37
This Earth was destroyed when it was torn asunder by collision with Earth-9, toppling into one another, because of a Bleed quake caused by a Monitor who did not follow the protocol.

Earth-Majestic
This Earth is a parallel universe that co-exists as one with the Earth of the main Smallville universe. It is referred to as Earth-Majestic and its designation is unknown. It derives this name from its greatest superhero Mister Majestic, the alternate version of Superman. This Earth is the latest target of the Monitors, as they have already started the process to decimate it. It was later destroyed like the other Earths before it with the consciousness of Jor-El being the last survivor of this universe.

Earth-Omega
This Earth is a parallel universe that co-exists as one with the Earth of the main Smallville universe. It is referred to as Earth "Omega" and its designation is unknown. It derives this name from the Omega symbol, which is used by Darkseid. This Earth was attacked and seized by Apokolips and the two planets have collided with each other. Among the ruins are several fallen ships that belonged to the Monitors, wrecked Manhunters and skeletons of dead people. This Earth hasn't been destroyed entirely yet because when the Monitors arrived there, Darkseid had already conquered that world. A catastrophic battle followed between the two parts, destroying almost everything around them. However the Monitors, who even though suffered many casualties, succeeded to break Darkseid. After Superman made a deal with Darkseid, he gave him the crystal shard that contains the presence of Jor-El from Earth-Majestic. Darkseid threw the shard into the distance and a fortress of solitude formed, with Darkseid saying it could be a new beginning, a "New Genesis."

Unidentified Earth (Apocalypse)
This unidentified Earth is a parallel universe that co-exists as one with the Earth of the main Smallville universe. In this universe, Kal-El's ship never made it to Earth. There is a human Clark Kent, who is the son of Jonathan and Martha Kent. Kara Zor-El was found and raised by Lionel Luthor, who named her "Linda Danvers". After Lex Luthor became President, Lex unleashed a nuclear holocaust upon the world.
 
Probably no, since the own Smallville series calls the Smallville main universe Earth-1 and its parallel universe Earth-2, when they are not the same as Arrowverse Earth-1 and 2. They could be part of the Pre-Crisis Arrowverse Multiverse but its just that whoever put their numbers has a different criteria than whoever puts them in the Arrowverse.
unknown-187.png
 
As for Smallville's Earth-9, assuming it's the same Earth-9 as Titans' Earth, they established in Crisis that the Monitor (Mar Novu) can restore worlds but he just couldn't during CoIE because the Anti-Monitor (his cosmic opposite) was draining his power.

Since the "Monitors" in Smallville season 11 were essentially Weaponers of Qward under a new name, that's not gonna affect Mar Novu directly so he easily could have restored the worlds destroyed by Smallville's Crisis unbeknownst to the characters and the readers. (I do recall Superman said when sending the female "Monitor"/Weaponer to the Phantom Zone that the death caused by Crisis wouldn't be undone, but that was as far as he knew and likely not the case.)
 

Latest posts

Back
Top