Pro Bot
Well-Known Member
and I'll fight you on that.And
Star City 2046 being retconned to an alternate Earth.
and I'll fight you on that.And
Star City 2046 being retconned to an alternate Earth.
1. Time travel doesn't mean multiversal travel.Elaborate, please.
Maybe in Crisis they travelled in early 2046, whereas in the LoT episode, they travelled in late 2046?1. Time travel doesn't mean multiversal travel.
2. Oliver didn't know Sarah was alive, yet remembers her leaving in the Legends of Tomorrow 2046 alternate Earth-1 future.
3. Oliver looks different.
So unless Oliver got amnesia and grew gray hair quickly, as well as the wave rider travelling to other universes, the Legends of Tomorrow episode is on Earth-1, not Earth-16.
I thought about that, but it still doesn't explain why Earth-16's Oliver is so different to Earth-1's Oliver. The DC's Legends of Tomorrow episode took too many references to the Earth-1 timeline while Crisis on Infinite Earths made it clear that this Olivier doesn't even have a living Sarah.Maybe in Crisis they travelled in early 2046, whereas in the LoT episode, they travelled in late 2046?
I'm just glad we got confirmation on that.Sooo:
New Earth-2 = Stargirl
Earth-9 = Titans
New Earth-19 = Swamp Thing
Earth-21 = Doom Patrol
That's rather disappointing that they're separate...but hopefully that changes at some point because I'm not fond of the idea of them being separate.
Is there even an Earth-1 now? I have faint hopes of those four I mentioned (and the DCEU) merging at some point thanks to the DCEU version of Flashpoint. Hell, they may have planted the seeds of that with the Ezra Miller Flash cameo.
More consistent for those viewing the shows too.Now every single DC-CW shows are set on the same Earth, including Supergirl & Black Lightning, very good!
I think it'll be easier for the timeline for future episodes !
Now the future crossovers will imply city-travelling, and not universe-travelling!More consistent for those viewing the shows too.
Yes, since Earth-Prime isn't "Earth-1 but with Earth-38 and Earth-BL" but a whole new Earth!Should I go back and label all the pre-Crisis Earth-1 events with [Earth-1]?